Tuesday, February 23, 2010

Comparing film reviews

Questions

Review A

Review B

What`s the title of the review?

Blacker than black

Serious man

Where did the review appear? If it is an Internet reference, give that.

IMDB

Rolling Stones magazine

What`s the name of the reviewer?

Unkown

Peter Travers

Does a photo accompany the review? If so, who or what is shown in the photo?

Yes, the actors and scenes from the movie

No

What features of the film does the reviewer discuss?

The work of the director mostly but also the comedy.

The plot, the characters and the work of the directors.

What features of the film, if any, does the reviewer like?

The black humour of the movie, the work of the directors and the prologue.

He liked the actors, especially Aaron Wolff and Micheal Stuhlbarg, and the boldness of the directors.

What features of the film, if any, does the reviewer dislike?

He doesn't mention nothing he disliked in particular.

He doesn't mention any

Does the reviewer recommend seeing the film?

Yes.

Yes.

What star rating, if any, does the reviewer given the film?

Review A

9/10


3.5 stars


The critic points out that the movie is unique and that it speaks for itself, the Coen brother, the directors did a wonderful job creating one of the best black comedies. It is the kind of movie that makes us think afterwards.

Review B

P.Travers mostly writes a brief summary of the movie, highlighting the best actors and the good choice of characters. He also admires the work of the Coen brothers for doing such an outstanding and stereotyped movie.

No comments:

Post a Comment